Forums

A request to those whose paper 8 is exempt and exams are over.

Accountancy

My Balance sheet for Amalgamation question did not tally. I want your help to point out where my mistake is. Please. This seemingly easy question gave me a sleepless night. I have attached my answer with workings for Question 3(a). Where is my mistake? How much marks can I expect out of 15?

20201206_130906.jpg
20201206_130753.jpg
20201206_130531.jpg
20201206_130823.jpg

Kumarjit Dey

Kumarjit Dey

CA Inter

4K+

06-Dec-20 13:11

323

Answers (7)

Best Answer

No Goodwill or Capital Reserve?


CA Suraj Lakhotia

CA Suraj Lakhotia

Admin

07-Dec-20 15:59

Workings in 3 attachment, Balance Sheet in 2nd.


Thread Starter

Kumarjit Dey

Kumarjit Dey

CA Inter

4K+

06-Dec-20 13:12

I am 100% sure atleast my workings are right. Fraction ( of debentures ) could be an issue though. But even that cant amount to such huge difference in totals. Reserves of transferor wont become that of transferee because amalgamation is in nature of Purchase.


Thread Starter

Kumarjit Dey

Kumarjit Dey

CA Inter

4K+

06-Dec-20 13:18

And one more thing. It could be a problem of 'Merger and Purchase'. But two things to be noted: the problem does not explicitly say that new cpmpany has taken over ALL the assets and liabilities. Number 2, in the last line it is said " amalgamation is to be carried out in the nature of purchase", in which case the General Reserve, Revaluation Reserve and P&L of transferors should not belong to/be adapted in transferee's books. Could, perhaps, the question be wrongly framed?


Thread Starter

Kumarjit Dey

Kumarjit Dey

CA Inter

4K+

06-Dec-20 13:39

-_-


Thread Starter

Kumarjit Dey

Kumarjit Dey

CA Inter

4K+

07-Dec-20 13:10

CA Suraj Lakhotia Admin

No Goodwill or Capital Reserve?

Oh God. The sillest of mistakes!


Thread Starter

Kumarjit Dey

Kumarjit Dey

CA Inter

4K+

07-Dec-20 18:41

CA Suraj Lakhotia Admin

No Goodwill or Capital Reserve?

Sir, debentures of High Ltd. will be settled by way of 86.67 lacs and of Low Ltd. by way of 48.53 Lacs. Any cash to be paid to them for fractio of debentures or anything like that is required to affect cash outflow?


Thread Starter

Kumarjit Dey

Kumarjit Dey

CA Inter

4K+

07-Dec-20 20:45

Offer
CFA Webinar
ibs launch
Tally + Excel Free