Forums

Back

AS 29

Accountancy

The answer given to the question is option c but how is it, Please clarify me

Screenshot 2024-12-23 180521.png

NANDHINI U S

NANDHINI U S

CA Inter

37K+

23-Dec-24 18:08

695

Answers (4)

1.Provision is a probable outflow of cash (must be settled to the lawyer irrespective of win or lose) 2.Contingent liabilities are not probable ( if z ltd wins they don't want to pay otherwise it must pay there is fifty fifty chances ) So the provision was rs.50k and contingent liabilities was rs 5L


but it is a case filed by Z Ltd against Y Ltd and the lawyers of Y Ltd have advised that the company ( Y Ltd) is likely to lose and that the chance of paying the claim is not remote - it doesn't mean that the Z Ltd will possibly win and get the claim which will be contingent asset


Thread Starter

NANDHINI U S

NANDHINI U S

CA Inter

37K+

23-Dec-24 20:19

Thread Starter

NANDHINI U S

but it is a case filed by Z Ltd against Y Ltd and the lawyers of Y Ltd have advised that the company ( Y Ltd) is likely to lose and that the chance of paying the claim is not remote - it doesn't mean that the Z Ltd will possibly win and get the claim which will be contingent asset

Question is not worded properly. If Z ltd loses, they wont have to pay out anything. And the question is not clear on this either.


CA Suraj Lakhotia

CA Suraj Lakhotia

Admin

24-Dec-24 17:04

Thank you Sir


Thread Starter

NANDHINI U S

NANDHINI U S

CA Inter

37K+

28-Dec-24 11:04

Your Reply