powered by logo

Forums

Back

Chapter 10 - Hire Purchase - Illustration 8 - IL Course video 24.

Accountancy

Hello, In the above mentioned question it is given that the amount due to hire vendor is paid in 3 equal installments together with interest, Kindly clarify if this means the 3 installments should be equal and we should find the installment value using PV/Annuity formula or only the principal repayment in those installment should be equal and actually installment value can differ(as shown in video). Thank you.


Aswin Chandar

Aswin Chandar

CA Final

40K+

04-Jan-23 13:08

641

Answers (15)

Best Answer

Thread Starter

Aswin Chandar

Ok, But still I need clarification for my initial question. @MODERATORS @ADMIN @FACULTY. Thankyou.

If the question just says 3 equal instalments - then you apply the annuity formula and compute equal instalments. The payment each year would be same. If the question says 3 instalments with interest - it is assumed that principal is divided in 3 parts and principal + interest accrued is paid.


CA Suraj Lakhotia

CA Suraj Lakhotia

Admin

09-Jan-23 07:34

Installments will be equal with different interest amount but same principal value


Shankari C

Shankari C

CA Inter

12K+

04-Jan-23 15:37

Shankari C

Installments will be equal with different interest amount but same principal value

Hey if Installment value and principal repayment is same in every year, interest should be equal which isn't possible so kindly reconsider your answer. Thank you.


Thread Starter

Aswin Chandar

Aswin Chandar

CA Final

40K+

04-Jan-23 15:45

ð???


SNEHAL KHANDELWAL

SNEHAL KHANDELWAL

CA Final

8K+

04-Jan-23 18:13

No... interest will be on cash price..so my answer is right


Shankari C

Shankari C

CA Inter

12K+

04-Jan-23 19:03

Shankari C

No... interest will be on cash price..so my answer is right

Lets say amount due is 180,000 and equal instalments are 60000 each, then interest for 1st period would be on 180k and interest for 2nd period would be on (180k - principal repaid) which would be less than interest for 1st period. @moderators kindly comment if I am right and help me with the above doubt. Thankyou.


Thread Starter

Aswin Chandar

Aswin Chandar

CA Final

40K+

05-Jan-23 08:16

Shankari C

This is right only..

Ok, But still I need clarification for my initial question. @MODERATORS @ADMIN @FACULTY. Thankyou.


Thread Starter

Aswin Chandar

Aswin Chandar

CA Final

40K+

07-Jan-23 11:20

Its done that way only right?


CA Suraj Lakhotia

CA Suraj Lakhotia

Admin

09-Jan-23 07:38

CA Suraj Lakhotia Admin

Its done that way only right?

The question says "equal installments with interest" so shouldn't the 3 installments be equal and we should use annuity formula?


Thread Starter

Aswin Chandar

Aswin Chandar

CA Final

40K+

09-Jan-23 07:42

Pls share the full sentence


CA Suraj Lakhotia

CA Suraj Lakhotia

Admin

09-Jan-23 07:45

CA Suraj Lakhotia Admin

Pls share the full sentence

Equal installments with interest is assumed to be equal principals + interest thereon.


CA Suraj Lakhotia

CA Suraj Lakhotia

Admin

09-Jan-23 16:24

CA Suraj Lakhotia Admin

Equal installments with interest is assumed to be equal principals + interest thereon.

Ok thanks for the clarification sir.


Thread Starter

Aswin Chandar

Aswin Chandar

CA Final

40K+

09-Jan-23 16:32

Your Reply