Forums

Doubt

Accountancy

Sir in this point no.4 if I Dr. Naveen a/c instead of purchase account is it is wrong ?

IMG_20201111_181422.jpg

Sri kanaga Varshini

Sri kanaga Varshini

CA Final

3K+

11-Nov-20 18:16

386

Answers (3)

Wrong Reasons: 1.By writing Naveen a/c he will become debtor but in given question it is said that cash payment was done since cash discount was given only in case of payment 2. Hence u can't debit Naveen A/C


Mr Spoidy

Mr Spoidy

CA Final

195

11-Nov-20 18:41

Mr Spoidy

Wrong Reasons: 1.By writing Naveen a/c he will become debtor but in given question it is said that cash payment was done since cash discount was given only in case of payment 2. Hence u can't debit Naveen A/C

It could be a credit purchase so earlier naveen would be in CR , now I am making payment so by Dr. Naveen I reduced liability.also now I am making payment so I received cash discount. My point of view is this... then how it will be wrong?


Thread Starter

Sri kanaga Varshini

Sri kanaga Varshini

CA Final

3K+

11-Nov-20 18:44

Thread Starter

Sri kanaga Varshini

It could be a credit purchase so earlier naveen would be in CR , now I am making payment so by Dr. Naveen I reduced liability.also now I am making payment so I received cash discount. My point of view is this... then how it will be wrong?

If earlier recorded as creditor for that amount ur opinion is correct. But logically if trade discount and cash discount given simultaneously it's reasonable to assume that immediate payment was inneciated and paid accordingly


Mr Spoidy

Mr Spoidy

CA Final

195

11-Nov-20 18:50

Offer