powered by logo

Forums

Back

Doubt

Accountancy

Sir have a small doubt in ill7 sir when I am using sacrificing ratio I am getting C as gaining and A as sacrificing but when I used gaining ration formulae I am getting A as gaining and C as sacrificing Sir which formulae should be used for the illustration and how to know which one should be used in which case (sacrificing ratio or gaining ratio) for every problem

53bd67f2-8d83-4c97-9857-9506b0f66b6b.jpg
d2c03f06-b8bb-4ca0-b28e-4a9b91c89785.jpg
f4ab70cd-2e83-414c-81fc-da25f865fe11.jpg

sai t

sai t

CA Foundation

★ 2K+

30-Nov-20 14:29

779

Answers (13)

Best Answer

Answer will be same

Attachments

IMG20201130174527.jpg

When you are using sacrifing ratio, if your answer comes in negative it means he is gaining.. your soultion is correct. A is gaining in both the cases


Abhishek Verma

Abhishek Verma

CA Inter

★ 7K+

30-Nov-20 16:39

Sacrificing ratio Answer in minus means he gaining Gaining ratio Answer in minus means he is sacrificing


Abhishek Verma

Abhishek Verma

CA Inter

★ 7K+

30-Nov-20 16:41

Abhishek Verma

When you are using sacrifing ratio, if your answer comes in negative it means he is gaining.. your soultion is correct. A is gaining in both the cases

When their is no new ratio is give how to calculate sacrificing ratio


Thread Starter

sai t

sai t

CA Foundation

★ 2K+

30-Nov-20 17:35

Thread Starter

sai t

When their is no new ratio is give how to calculate sacrificing ratio

how to calculate sacrificing ratio for above problem

Attachments

2cc40604-8acf-45f4-bbeb-eb893a755aa2.jpg

Thread Starter

sai t

sai t

CA Foundation

★ 2K+

30-Nov-20 17:36

Abhishek Verma

When you are using sacrifing ratio, if your answer comes in negative it means he is gaining.. your soultion is correct. A is gaining in both the cases

how to calculate sacrificing ratio for example 1 Other than old ratio as sacrificing ratio is their any other method to calculate

Attachments

13cb4213-215a-469e-ab8a-a55c50c2e2fe.jpg

Thread Starter

sai t

sai t

CA Foundation

★ 2K+

30-Nov-20 17:38

If there is no ratio is given, then the old ratio of partner treated as sacrifing ratio


Abhishek Verma

Abhishek Verma

CA Inter

★ 7K+

30-Nov-20 17:43

Thread Starter

sai t

how to calculate sacrificing ratio for above problem

In this case profit sharing ratio 2:2:1 is sacrificing ratio


Abhishek Verma

Abhishek Verma

CA Inter

★ 7K+

30-Nov-20 17:44

I think you understood


Abhishek Verma

Abhishek Verma

CA Inter

★ 7K+

30-Nov-20 17:50

Abhishek Verma

Answer will be same

Thank you


Thread Starter

sai t

sai t

CA Foundation

★ 2K+

30-Nov-20 18:22

Abhishek Verma

I think you understood

Yes now concept was clear


Thread Starter

sai t

sai t

CA Foundation

★ 2K+

30-Nov-20 18:22

Your Reply