powered by logo

Forums

Back

House property

Direct Taxation

Here in this question , fair rent , municipal value , are to be given for each unit i.e. ground floor / first floor , so it is to be taken full for LOP ..but in solution , it is taken half of everything ..like 36k mv , 50 k fair rent ..why not full amount as it has mentioned the word each and in bracket ground floor/ first floor

5f8f6ce3-e8c5-46a0-a3c3-b15c4e2a5b82.jpg

Samridhi Sareen

Samridhi Sareen

CA Inter

★ 830

24-Sep-23 19:08

994

Answers (4)

Since Mr. Naveen has utilised the HP for residential purpose the same shall be treated as SOP and GAV is taken as NIL. Whereas, Mr. Vikas has let out till 31.12.23 and later he has self occupied but the same is to be treated as LOP only. And as mentioned in the question, both have equal areas, therefore all the figures are halved for Mr. Vikas i.e. in the proportion of the areas.


Sagar Kathuria

Since Mr. Naveen has utilised the HP for residential purpose the same shall be treated as SOP and GAV is taken as NIL. Whereas, Mr. Vikas has let out till 31.12.23 and later he has self occupied but the same is to be treated as LOP only. And as mentioned in the question, both have equal areas, therefore all the figures are halved for Mr. Vikas i.e. in the proportion of the areas.

But i have a doubt as they said Naveen and vikas CONSTRUCTED THEIR HOUSES that means they both have separate houses properties from each other ..moreover municipal value , fair rent everything is given for each unit ( ground floor / first floor ) that means for groung floor 100000 fair rent and for first floor 100000 fair rent ..

Attachments

4f217c1e-5705-4187-aa21-d8e55a0bb148.jpg

Thread Starter

Samridhi Sareen

Samridhi Sareen

CA Inter

★ 830

25-Sep-23 00:37

Can u pls share the solution


Sagar Kathuria

Sagar Kathuria

CA Final

★ 3K+

25-Sep-23 12:56

Sagar Kathuria

Can u pls share the solution

Got the point .it is taken because the period from which he started using house property is 1-10 to 31-3 ..so from 6 months period , he is using the property for self occupation as well as let out ..therefore it is taken half of everything ..this is the concept when property is acquired or constructed in between the previous year

Attachments

ef39d8f9-e030-4405-99aa-9867a3c25737.jpg

Thread Starter

Samridhi Sareen

Samridhi Sareen

CA Inter

★ 830

25-Sep-23 13:32

Your Reply