Forums
Back
ICAI VALUATION - CA INTER.
Exams
Actually I got papers through RTI act recently. I had applied for revaluation also and they told that there are no changes in marks. But for this question I wrote answer which is similar in my ICAI material but ICAI gave me 0 out of 4 marks( not even half marks) can anyone please help me in this? This is not the only question. I have many questions in this similar type.
Answers (21)
sriman narayana
Sometimes icai correction is like that we can't do anything in this aspect What we can do is that we can only apply for revaluation
Oh ok i hv also applied for revaluation. But there is no change in marks. Even ICAI totalling is wrong . Idk where to tell these.
Thread Starter
V U LakshmiOh ok i hv also applied for revaluation. But there is no change in marks. Even ICAI totalling is wrong . Idk where to tell these.
If correct totalling give any effect to u r aggregate or exemption u can send mail to u icai regarding your totalling. if correct total doesn't impact u r aggregate or u r exemption u may not considered it as problem
Swetha S
I believe answer is not to the point. Question states that higher management is associated with manipulation of accounts, then answer should be related to that. The answer you stated is general in nature
But in ICAI material that heading is also mentioning to same point right?
1. There is no concept of revaluation in ICAI. It is only verification. 2. There cannot be an error in totaling as it is system driven. 3. The answer you wrote would have fetched you at the most 1 mark out of 4. You need to elaborate slightly in the context of the question. Also you need to frame an answer with respect to the names etc given in the question. What you have shared is just a summary. You should also refer to the elaborate points given under 2.2.
Thread Starter
V U LakshmiBut in ICAI material that heading is also mentioning to same point right?
Heading is correct only but itâ??s that specific to the questions asked. If you are IL student then you can refer Satya Sir Lectures. I think lectures are free today, please go through it you will get clarityâ?¦.
CA Suraj Lakhotia Admin
1. There is no concept of revaluation in ICAI. It is only verification. 2. There cannot be an error in totaling as it is system driven. 3. The answer you wrote would have fetched you at the most 1 mark out of 4. You need to elaborate slightly in the context of the question. Also you need to frame an answer with respect to the names etc given in the question. What you have shared is just a summary. You should also refer to the elaborate points given under 2.2.
Oh ok sir thanks. But ICAI gave 0 marks that's where i got doubt. Totalling error is there sir I got 10 out of 70 but that's unexpected and its due to these kind of corrections but i got 42 out of 100 that's not possible i don't know why they are not letting us know MCQ marks separately.
Shankari C
Icai is not fair in this aspect.Really disappointed to know this.Definitely we should voice out this
Ya sure im gonna mail them and see