powered by logo

Forums

Back

Insurance claim

Accountancy

In module chapter 10 illustration 5 there is abnormal item which is taken at cost in memo trading account (opening stock) Whereas in illustration 1 abnormal item is taken in opening stock at cost - written off value why so??


AKSHA MEHTA

AKSHA MEHTA

CA Inter

2K+

09-Mar-23 18:24

510

Answers (7)

Pls share the question you are referring to.


CA Suraj Lakhotia

CA Suraj Lakhotia

Admin

09-Mar-23 19:41

Here's the question with red marking

Attachments

IMG-20230309-WA0006.jpg
IMG-20230309-WA0005.jpg

Thread Starter

AKSHA MEHTA

AKSHA MEHTA

CA Inter

2K+

09-Mar-23 20:24

This is because in illustration 5, The abnormal item is present in the godown at the time of fire, so it is shown separately in the memorandum trading account to ascertain stock on date of fire. In illustration 1, we can follow the alternative method given below for better understanding.


Neha Baliga

Neha Baliga

CA Inter

16K+

09-Mar-23 23:52

Thank you sir


motakapuvishnu Ram

motakapuvishnu Ram

CMA Inter

5

10-Mar-23 01:36

the stock in opening stock might have been sold at a different GP. So excluded to calculate stock based on normal GP. In Illustration 10, it should be a part of closing stock hence reversed.


CA Suraj Lakhotia

CA Suraj Lakhotia

Admin

10-Mar-23 17:25

pullagorla sivaram

Sir i also got same doubt sir today... I didn't get clarity sir... Would you pls explain clearly one more time sir

To calculate normal gross profit, we need to ensure the we calculate it using normal valuations. Say some part of opening stock is sold at loss or lower profit or higher profit. This will be excluded to ensure that it does not impact the calculation. If we have written off some amount from closing stock, we add it back to bring it to normal valuation just for the purpose of GP calculation.


CA Suraj Lakhotia

CA Suraj Lakhotia

Admin

20-Mar-23 10:00

Your Reply