Forums
The Indirect Labour Table
Costing
answered on 10-Dec-25 16:37
Sir, we didnt made use of the indirect labour hour table in the solution anywhere, instead we used 80% on direct labour as indirect OH. How can we identify which information we should ignore while solving solution.
latest answer
The rate was based on previous month. In such cases we computed what was the rate applied (generally as a %). You will get a hold of this with practice.
Vinod Kumar
CA Inter
★ 11K+
1
121
Earning Value of the company
AFM
answered on 05-Dec-25 11:01
Sir, I understand that the earning value of the company represents the total value that both equity and debt investors would be willing to invest today in order to receive the company’s future earnings (such as EBIT or FCFF) at their expected rate of return (WACC/Ke). Am I right, sir?
latest answer
Yeah sort of right
Murali Thripuraboina
CA Final
★ 3K+
1
110
Present value is more than cash received.
Financial Reporting
answered on 10-Dec-25 10:22
Sir, in this Illustration , the calculated Present Value of the liability is Rs. 104.22 crores, which is higher than the Rs. 100 crores cash received. How should this excess amount be treated upon initial recognition? [Video Time Stamp: 09:17]
latest answer
If embedded derivative is accounted as separately we will follow derivative principles. Every period end we will check FV and gain or loss will be recognised in PL
K Vamshi
CA Final
★ 14K+
3
141
Doubt
Direct Taxation
answered on 19-Dec-25 19:39
Q19 Q20 Doubt direct taxation ca inter
latest answer
What is the doubt ?
vaishali vadhera
CA Inter
★ 0
1
139
Effective Interest Rate
Financial Reporting
answered on 09-Dec-25 20:19
Sir, for illustration 36, shouldn't we have found the effective interest rate for calculating interest amount.?
latest answer
Okay Sir, thank you.
K Vamshi
CA Final
★ 14K+
2
130
Provision
Financial Reporting
answered on 09-Dec-25 14:46
In the Ind As 37 on one side they are saying for provision- future amount is uncertain on the other side they are saying provisin has ability to measure i am bit confused between this. Also Highlighted the words in pages artached. Also amount payable for electricity they said it is not provison as its accrual but in articleship everywhere rent of current month shown as provision only
latest answer
A provision is a liability of uncertain timing or amount. (So either timing is uncertain or amount is uncertain) A provision is recognised when: The entity has a present obligation (legal or constructive) as a result of a past event. It is probable that an outflow of resources will be required to settle the obligation. A reliable estimate of the amount can be made. (Since outflow is probable >50%, we make an estimate and record it) Accrual is where the amount can be measured. For e.g .in case of electricity we know how many units are consumed. IN true sense this is accrual. in real life we use provision and accrual interchangeably (especially in India) So for e.g Salary expense is accrued - we do not create a provision.
Gauri Shete
CA Final
★ 5K+
1
126
illustration 1 , initial measurement
Financial Reporting
answered on 09-Dec-25 14:46
where is the question in that given answer in this vedio sir.. no question directly u gave an answer
latest answer
This is an example taken. NOt a specific question.
leela sowjanya
CA Final
★ 10
1
107
exclusion from PPE
Financial Reporting
answered on 09-Dec-25 14:59
In investment property you said that i have many lands and buildings to sell and buy is the business, so here IND AS 16 deals right, because of it is supply of goods and services, but in biological assets topic you told that many dogs are here to sell , here it is supply of goods and services so why it is deals with AS 41 not dealt by AS 16 as same as investment property topic. [Video Time Stamp: 17:09]
latest answer
initial accounting under Ind AS 41. Say puppies at birth to be measured at FV less cost to sell. If the dogs are trained subsequently and then sold - we will cover under ind As 2. At this point you do not need go further to such advanced level.
leela sowjanya
CA Final
★ 10
4
150
Government grant
Financial Reporting
answered on 04-Dec-25 16:11
Grant received where can I show in cashflow statement, whether in investing or financing activity, what is the reason behind it?
latest answer
Both views have been accepted. As per ICAI If it is in relation to an asset - show it under investing activity separately (without netting it off). As per Expert Advisory Committee - Investing As per Staff Report on IFRS - Financing. Relevant Text below _____ A staff paper on examples illustrating the classification of cash flows was presented in IFRS Interpretations Committee meeting of July 2012 wherein example 5 considered the issue of presentation of government grant received to compensate for the cost of purchasing new equipment in statement of cash flows. The staff paper can be accessed from the link https://cdn.ifrs.org/-/media/feature/meetings/2012/july/interpretations-committee/031207ap03ias7examplesillustratingclassificationcashflows.pdf. The staff paper evaluates two presentation principles: i. As financing activity This determines that a grant represents a source of financing for the entity and the government is acting as a capital provider. ii. As investing activity This looks at the transaction financed by the grant instead of the grant itself. In addition, proponents of this view may observe that paragraph 28 of Ind AS 20 implies that the government grant may be deducted from the related item for presentation purposes. The staff have expressed their support for first principle because the grant is providing a source of financing to the entity; and consequently, cash received should be part of the entity’s financing activities. The staff have disagreed with the second principle because it would mean focusing on the nature of the transaction that is financed by the grant instead of the nature of the grant itself.
santhu mallikarjuna reddy gali
CA Final
★ 29K+
1
153
Ind AS 116 Illustration-35
Financial Reporting
answered on 04-Dec-25 16:12
Here reduction in office space is 50% but reduction in lease payment is only 40%. How did we chose 50%? (should we consider higher of 50% or 40%)? [Video Time Stamp: 15:05]
latest answer
As far as the right of use is concerned, it has reduced by 50%.
rashid poonthala
CA Final
★ 31K+
1
103