powered by logo

Forums

Why Direct and Indirect Taxation ?

Direct Taxation

answered on 03-Aug-22 09:11

If an assessee is having an income of Rs 10 lakhs. Then he will pay tax on that Rs 10 lakhs. So that income of Rs 10 lakhs is tax paid income. After that, I purchase some groceries worth Rs 5,000 .But again I am paying GST on that Rs 5,000, which I have already paid the income tax on it. So, Is this not a cascading effect or double taxation ? Is there any chance that Income tax will be removed in the coming years or decade and only ONE NATION ONE TAX will prevail ?

latest answer

GST is tax on consumption and Income tax is tax on income While it may appear it is double taxation, the fact is both are of diff nature and intended for diff purposes. GOI needs revenue, hence then need to levy taxes at various points to collect that .

Avasarala Vivek Aditya

Avasarala Vivek Aditya

CA Inter

★ 6K+

9

620

Marginal relief

Direct Taxation

answered on 08-Aug-22 00:03

Answer is (b) 12,67,600.. I got wrong answer, can anyone give me calculations?

latest answer

Thank you for the same

Sajeetha R

Sajeetha R

CA Final

★ 46K+

3

705

Salaries

Direct Taxation

answered on 02-Aug-22 13:28

In illustration 12, on computation of taxable value of perquisite, 'treatment of Mr. G's sister (dependent) in a nursing home' is not regarded as exempt. Whereas explanation to proviso to section 17(2) states that hospital includes a dispensary or a clinic or a nursing home. When [in what case (eg.) ], the above explanation is applicable?

latest answer

Yes the hospital includes nursing Home, but it should be maintened by the employer or it should be a government /government aided hospital.. In question they has not mentioned about the nursing home as employor 's or government or government aided, So only this not exempt

Rinuja TK

Rinuja TK

CA Inter

★ 10K+

1

528

TIME OF SUPPLY

Indirect Taxation

answered on 04-Aug-22 18:30

Time of supply of goods under forward charge [12(2)].. Is there any provisions regarding composite supplier ? For nov 2022

latest answer

Date of payment is not relevant in case of goods general rule. As per general rule, DOI means actual date of invoice and last date on which invoice is ought to have been issued under Section 31 whichever is earlier.

Prakash Murugan

Prakash Murugan

CA Inter

★ 710

8

602

#2 Inter: Question of the day

Corporate & Other Laws

answered on 02-Aug-22 22:03

Answer by 8pm. Write the answer as you will write in the exam in your sheet/copy and share photo. Examine the validity of the following statement referring to the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013 and/or Rules: 'The Articles of Association of X Ltd. contained a provision that upto 4% of issue price of the shares may be paid as underwriting commission to the underwriters. The Board of Directors of X Ltd. decided to pay 5% underwriting commission.'

latest answer

Thankyou sir

Sahibdeep Singh

Sahibdeep Singh

CA Inter

★ 14K+

17

3K+

Explanation 2 to Section 9 (1) (i)

Direct Taxation

answered on 02-Aug-22 06:35

"Merchandise" - meaning?

latest answer

Goods

Girinath A

Girinath A

CA Inter

★ 765

1

447

AS-2

Accountancy

answered on 02-Aug-22 09:36

Need explanation with example This standard does not apply to Work in progress arising in the ordinary course of business of service provider

latest answer

AS-2 doesn't apply to the Work in Progress (WIP)means service which are partially provided during the end of the financial year

Nikita Rajpurohit

Nikita Rajpurohit

CA Inter

★ 0

2

599

Cost of capital - present value

Financial Management

answered on 05-Aug-22 09:04

Whether these present value, future value will be given by ICAI itself in exams ,or we have to derive them?

latest answer

This has also been explained in our videos. ( 1/(1+rate)) and then GT if you require sum of all PVs

Sri Yoga Vishwa. P

Sri Yoga Vishwa. P

CA Final

★ 2K+

7

474

Doubt

Corporate & Other Laws

answered on 02-Aug-22 09:44

Sir can u pls explain the meaning of this paragraph

latest answer

If alteration is done with the consent of the party , and party who made the alteration , both of them have no right to complain about the alteration . As the example given in the para , the date on cheque can be voluntarily altered by the drawer for revalidation of the same , he cannot say that as the material alteration is done , the cheque becomes void , he has no advantage of saying it . Note : It is always open to a drawer to voluntarily revalidate the negotiable instrument including the cheque .

Sri kanaga Varshini

Sri kanaga Varshini

CA Final

★ 3K+

2

492

Quorum

Corporate & Other Laws

answered on 03-Aug-22 14:19

Whether a chairman is included while calculating Quorum?

latest answer

Never mind mam

Abhay .

Abhay .

CA Final

★ 10K+

6

665