Forums
Objection on two cases
Corporate & Other Laws
answered on 09-Jun-25 08:39
Lily White vs R mannuswamy The decision was in favour of Lily as the condition was not reasonable Mukul Datta vs Indian airlines The decision as per video is in favour of Indian airlines stating that the passenger has accepted the condition But as per official data of the supreme court of India the decision is in favour of mukul Datta with a compensation In both cases conditions should be reasonable In case of mukul Datta vs Indian airlines the condition should be reasonable which is not What should be the final judgement in case of mukul data and if yes why condition should be reasonable in case of mukul Datta
latest answer
Yes it is a case of tacit acceptance.
Gurukanta Singh
CA Inter
★ 20K+
4
669
TDS rates
Direct Taxation
answered on 28-May-25 22:06
TDS rate on sale of property of non resident for AY 2026-2027
latest answer
If seller is NR then the tds rate shall be 12.5 + surcharge if applicable + HEC
Georgekutty scaria
CA Inter
★ 4K+
1
308
Beta of Debt
AFM
answered on 28-May-25 16:52
Sir, the beta of debt is often assumed to be zero, because debt payments are generally fixed and do not fluctuate with market conditions. Can you please explain when the Beta of debt will not be zero, and which factors indicate that the Beta of debt is not zero?
latest answer
When risk of non payment of Company's debt's is linked to economic conditions then debt beta is not equal to zero. Even if it is non zero it is very small number
Chaitanya Sai Gupta
CA Final
★ 4K+
1
302
Questions
AFM
answered on 28-May-25 10:03
Where is solution of this question in book ???
latest answer
Hi, This question has been added specifically for May 25 syllabus by ICAI. As and when ICAI adds new questions in ICAI SM , and when they ask new type of questions in the Exams, we add them to video content. Obviously it will not be possible to add them all to the printed Material as changes are frequent We add them to PDF notes. We will be uploading a new version of PDF notes along with questions asked in May 25 exams by 31st may 2025 - the revised notes have additional information on source of questions as well. kindly wait for 3 more days Secondly the same question was earlier covered in the business valuation chapter and that is still there too. Just search for external financing requirement in PDF of P 600 + and you will be able to locate the solution
Akash Nanda
CA Final
★ 25K+
1
264
VL=Vu+D×tax
Financial Management
answered on 28-May-25 10:32
@32.35 why D× tax explain logically
latest answer
D x t
anju B
CA Inter
★ 21K+
1
209
EBIT VS EAESH
Financial Management
answered on 28-May-25 10:24
@27.5where EAESH is different from EBIT Because , tax part is exist b/w them results different answer EBIT-TAX=EAESH(no debt,no ps)
latest answer
Yes
anju B
CA Inter
★ 21K+
1
307
Which provision will come
Corporate & Other Laws
answered on 28-May-25 11:14
Which contract is this and what would be the answer in this
latest answer
It is implied communication of offer and implied acceptance.
Preeti Prajapati
CA Foundation
★ 0
1
288
D1 or D0
Financial Management
answered on 28-May-25 10:25
Sir ,I have a confusion always about how to identify whether the dividend is D1 or D0 in the question?
latest answer
When they say next year it is d1 It is based on simple reading of question only nothing beyond that
anju B
CA Inter
★ 21K+
1
301
Flotation cost in WACC market value
Financial Management
answered on 28-May-25 10:26
Why don't we subtract flotation cost by the computation of WACC @market value where for ex. Mps =24 flotation cost 4rs. Then 50000shares ×(net mps I e,) 20 rs instead of 24?
latest answer
Because floatation cost is specific to debt or equity or pref, adjustment should be made at their level and not WACC level
anju B
CA Inter
★ 21K+
1
245
Appropriation of payments
Corporate & Other Laws
answered on 28-May-25 11:14
Here,there is a payment of 12500rs that is paid to the creditor and there is a debt of 12500 rs.should we consider the amount of 12500 paid to clear the debt of 12500 rs or should we consider that amount is paid to clear the time barred debts? Pls provide the complete answer for this question
latest answer
Since no direction has been given on how to appropriate the payments the payment received can be appropriated against time barred debts.
likhith c
CA Foundation
★ 1K+
1
243