Forums
Amalgamation of accounts
Accountancy
answered on 26-Mar-26 10:31
From ICAI material pg 13.58 (d) point ; I haven’t understood the calculation of no. Of equity shares as 40000 shares , on what basis they have taken overall share capital for calculation of equity shares to be given on purchase of vayu Ltd
latest answer
The illustration is solved in class as well.
GUJJU VAISHNAVI
CA Inter
★ 13K+
2
52
Deemed pure Agent Service (vs) composite Supply of Rent & electricity
Indirect Taxation
answered on 02-Apr-26 16:48
I have a doubt regarding the GST valuation for electricity charges recovered by a Mall from its tenants. ⚡ The 'Deemed Pure Agent' Case: The provision suggests that if electricity is collected on an actual basis (even if the bill is in the Mall’s name), it is 'Deemed as a Pure Agent' and shall not form part of the value. ✅ The 'Composite Supply' Case: However, in Question for a shopping mall providing electricity as part of a composite supply (renting space), the answer is marked as Taxable, stating it is included in the value of rent—even if billed separately. ⚠️ My Specific Questions: ❓ How do we distinguish between a 'Deemed Pure Agent' recovery and a 'Composite Supply' in a real-world exam scenario? 📖 If a Mall recovers electricity charges on an actual basis but under a Rental Agreement, which rule takes precedence? 💡
latest answer
Practically it is always included and it is taxed.
Yogesh S
CA Final
★ 125
1
65
Circular permutations
Maths & Stats
answered on 26-Mar-26 22:24
Sir, while solving the question about arranging 7 boys around a circular table such that two particular boys never sit together, you first explained that without any restriction the number of ways is (7-1)! = 6! Then, to find the cases where those two boys always sit together, you said we can consider them as one unit. That makes it 6 places, but you mentioned it as 5 places. I am confused about this step. Could you explain it again?
latest answer
Arranging n boys around a circular table is done in (n-1)! ways. For 7 boys its 6! ways When 2 boys are always together then we take these 2 boys as one unit . Now n becomes 6 ( 2 boys as 1 unit + remaining 5 boys) . So total ways is (n-1)! which is 5!. Trust this clarifies
Mrittika
CA Foundation
★ 0
1
59
market price increase by 75 bps , then we take -ve duration.? beacuse of inverse relation with current price.? or formula always negative.?
AFM
answered on 25-Mar-26 09:41
change in price in this question
latest answer
Duration
Vinod Kumawat
CA Final
★ 1K+
1
39
Question
Financial Reporting
answered on 25-Mar-26 08:17
If additional dep is there due to increase in FV,it should decrease post acquisition profits.But in this q,it is increasing the same.
latest answer
Depreciation is reduced
SANSKRITI BADRI 2111339
CA Final
★ 4K+
1
31
at discount 4%
Costing
answered on 04-Apr-26 09:48
carring cost 4000/2 how come sir for discount [Video Time Stamp: 06:00]
latest answer
Average carrying cost. Average Inventory = (0+4000)/2
Jeevethan
CMA Inter
★ 0
1
63
Material uncertainty
Auditing
answered on 05-Apr-26 14:07
What is material uncertainty i didn't understand clearly mam..........could u please explain it with an example
latest answer
It’s mean The business may survive or may fail. The decision depends on uncertain future factors and this uncertainty is important enough to affect users’ decisions. A company has a huge loan due in 3 months, but: -It does not have enough cash -It is planning to get a new loan to repay the old one So, If the new loan is approved then company survives If not then company may shut down.
Nandhini Muthu
CA Inter
★ 2K+
1
50
SPOM vedios
Others
answered on 15-Apr-26 16:12
sir, there is an option to forward the spom classes in icai website, but is it okay to forward or is there any issues after getting classes completed fastly?
latest answer
Speed we can't increase Do two set video olby login same in two tab
leela sowjanya
CA Final
★ 10
5
73
Long term capital gain House property
Direct Taxation
answered on 24-Mar-26 18:47
I have a query regarding capital gains on a property sale. The property was purchased in 1996, transferred to the son in 2025(gift), and then sold in March 2026. Could you please clarify how the capital gain will be calculated in this scenario? Specifically, will indexation benefit be applicable, and should the purchase cost be considered from 1996, or the Fair Market Value as of April 1, 2001?
latest answer
We can consider the original cost or FMV on 1.4.2001 whichever is higher. Further, we have an option whether to go for indexation or no indexation.
David Prakash
CA Inter
★ 60
1
42
CA FINAL STUDY MATERIALS
Others
answered on 24-Mar-26 14:07
Good Afternoon sir, I have registered for ca final on march 14th 2026, but today is 24th march 2026, but still i have not received study materials from icai, so can u please tell me that within how many days study materials will come.
latest answer
Yes. Using coupon
leela sowjanya
CA Final
★ 10
4
64