Forums
Tax liability
Direct Taxation
answered on 10-Jan-25 16:08
If the question is silent about the calculation of tax liability either in new or old tax regime then which tax regime should we use to calculate tax liability
latest answer
Thank you
Mukesh Kumar
CA Inter
★ 0
2
685
Capital budgeting
Financial Management
answered on 01-Jan-25 10:49
Q.no 36 question is not explained directly jumped into the answer
latest answer
We have added the Question video before it. Kindly check and let us know in case you have any further queries
Keerthi Reddy D
CA Inter
★ 12K+
2
198
(AV -EV) or (EV -AV)
AFM
answered on 01-Jan-25 10:54
Sir why its AV-EV, why not its EV - AV ? Is it because say if Actual stock market perfomrs more than Expected so, AV-EV(Say 8 - 5 = 3) will have postiivve componenet which need to be added to Rf (if Rf is 4 then E(R) will be 4 +3 =7)(meaning market perfomed more so can expect more return), if we do EV-AV (5-8 = -3 )for the same thing, then E(R) will be 4-3 = 1, which is kind of wrong expected return we get so is this the logic ? In our formula sheet also its EV-AV as ICAI material
latest answer
Formula is AV- EV It is misprint in our old formula sheet as well as ICAI. We have corrected it subsequently in latest formula sheet on our website / app. you can check the same. I have explained the reason also in the explanation to this video
Hemachandra D
CA Final
★ 9K+
1
1K+
Actual Return/Expected Return
AFM
answered on 01-Jan-25 10:56
Sir ideally they should have name as Actual Return instead of Expected Return, as CAPM return also Expected return as CAPM return. or as you said we have to consider to compare with CAPM Expected Return vs some Expected Return or this question Am I right my uderstanding ?
latest answer
In the question it is not CAPM expected return. It is the return being expected by the investor This is very diff from CAPM return which is formula driven Actual return and investor expectation these two both fall on one side and CAPM expected return is on other side
Hemachandra D
CA Final
★ 9K+
1
2K+
Sir I completed revision practice concept revision and all mock test rtp past question papers of law I am 99%sure law paper exemption come
Exams
answered on 03-Jan-25 14:33
But sir my account area weak and tax also more more weak of leval preparation law August to May Law+account May to Oct Now law+ account + tax doing Sir is good for clearing group 1 Icai issue is if I got exemption then reaming 2 paper each subject 50 And sir vimp is icai count attempt after exemption in law If I not writen any attempt then each subject 40 ki jagah per dono remaining two paper me each subject me 50 50 above score karna hoga My question sir skip this attempt or writen in may because clearing entire G1 point of views I am 99 percentage that law and reaming two paper account tax I face later diffulty continuously thinking this Or I skip Jan attempt and writen May directly all paper
latest answer
If you get exemption in law, you do not need to score 50 in remaining papers. You can score 60 in law, 50 in Tax and 40 in accounts as well. Aggregate should be 150. Go through the revision lectures for accounts which we recently added. it will help you.
R G
CA Inter
★ 9K+
3
1K+
Ri, whether Actual Return or Expected Return
AFM
answered on 01-Jan-25 11:35
Sir it’s a confusion of what Ri should be in Treynor Ratio/Sharpe Ratio whether its actual return or Expected Return to be considered => In illustration 67, Expected Return is considered as Ri, I believe it is due to the non availability of actual retunr => In illustratoin 68, for treynor ratio raking, Ri = Expected Return considered despite Actual Return Given In illustration 80 Ri = Average of Actual Return Considered In illustration 82, Ri = Actual Return Considered I understood that you said actual return to be used as you check the ratios for actuals to know the performance would like to get some clarity especially considering, in Illustration 67 Expected Return used despite actuals available
latest answer
67 & 68 both are Optimal portfolio Questions - I have explained the formula as Treynor ratio so that you can remember it - actually please do not spend time on these 2 questions at all as they are a waste of time and effort and energy and will suck away a lot of time in exam - rather if it even appears in exam, do not attempt it and instead solve other problems In 67 ER is not CAPM Er but return expected by the user (as explained in one of your previous queries) in 68 Return values are historical and we are not sure what they are Actual or expected - this is a problem I downloaded from IIT Kanpur department of finance or something like that and they solved it this way - if it is too confusing ignore it 80 - average of actual return considered because they have not asked us to find out ratios for any specific year - just said find out - hence we computed the ratios over a 3 year period 82 - used actual as that is the right formula Long story short, as far as normal Treynor ratio questions are concerned, used actual if available, else use expected return by investor - under no circumstance use CAPM expected Optimal portfolio questions - completely ignore
Hemachandra D
CA Final
★ 9K+
1
519
doubt in the solution
Financial Management
answered on 31-Dec-24 13:11
hello sir, as the debtors were valued at selling price per unit (Rs.18) while computing no. of units, but at min2:35 in this video, the debtors rate per unit is taken at total cost per unit(Rs.16 for normal shift and Rs.12.4 for double shift) while computing cost of debtors. and in the question there is the mention of selling price will remain same so sir, my interpretation is that rpu of debtors should be Rs.18 for both single shift and double shift
latest answer
Faculty says total cost basis and not revenue basis. You can make an assumption on revenue basis. icai has also chosen to solve on cost basis and not ARPU basis
Nagachaitanya Nomula
CA Final
★ 8K+
1
270
Spom fast forward
Exams
answered on 31-Dec-24 08:46
Is there any way to watch spam videos in fast forward?
latest answer
No
Dipanshu Porwal
CA Final
★ 0
1
992
Deemed owner Matlab
Direct Taxation
answered on 31-Dec-24 21:48
Deemed owner Matlab deemed Matlab tax language me kaya hota hai
latest answer
I already understand I watched lecture no 21 of IFHP
R G
CA Inter
★ 9K+
2
778
NAV Change Percentage less than the target Change %
AFM
answered on 31-Dec-24 06:09
Sir what if the change month on month is less than the target % (15%), then no rebalancing happens if we compare with the previous month value instead of historic cost
latest answer
No rebalancing happens
Hemachandra D
CA Final
★ 9K+
1
765