powered by logo

Forums

Back

Loss due to vacancy & GAV

Direct Taxation

Hi sir/mam, I'm fully confused between what is taught in indigolearn lecture and notes given in ICAI, on arriving "GAV in case of vacancy loss". I'm getting different answers while solving using those 2 ways. Please explain what is the difference between the two? I have attached the pics of the 2 ways....

20220821_170749.jpg
20220821_165410.jpg

Girinath A

Girinath A

CA Inter

765

21-Aug-22 17:18

568

Answers (3)

Pls share the question and answers you got


CA Suraj Lakhotia

CA Suraj Lakhotia

Admin

21-Aug-22 18:29

CA Suraj Lakhotia Admin

Pls share the question and answers you got

Sir...... I have attached the question and answers

Attachments

20220821_201103.jpg
20220821_201152.jpg

Thread Starter

Girinath A

Girinath A

CA Inter

765

21-Aug-22 20:12

Thread Starter

Girinath A

Sir...... I have attached the question and answers

Both the concepts are same with different presentations. 1. Say, You let out the property for 10 months. Rent received is Rs. 14,000. So, total rent received for 10 months is Rs. 1,40,000. The difference of Rs. 1,000 is not due to vacancy. But it is because you collected less than reasonable. So, this is not a vacancy loss. 2. For remaining 2 months, you did not received any rent. The reason behind that was the house property was vacant. So, vacancy loss is Rs. 30,000 To make it more clear, Total reasonably expected rent for the year is Rs. 1,80,000 and loss due to vacancy is Rs. 30,000. So GAV is Rs. 1,50,000


Yoga Vishnu

Yoga Vishnu

CA Final

11K+

22-Aug-22 10:57

Your Reply