powered by logo

Forums

Back

NBFC

Accountancy

Jan 21 examination ques 3.b How will ICAI classify “75 accounts for 4 months ( Amt overdue 64 lakhs ) as STANDARD ASSET???

6F2CA003-CAE8-4B96-A88C-0FCBE53488CA.jpg
6525EA32-00F4-46F6-B3D4-F83ECADE5294.jpg

kowselyaa G

kowselyaa G

CA Final

2K+

06-Nov-23 15:03

539

Answers (11)

75 accounts for 4m is -Sub Std, i.e; >3m but <12m


It's a NBFC not a banking company. Provisions for NBFC are different


Ashwin Kumar

Ashwin Kumar

CA Inter

12K+

06-Nov-23 20:13

Yes .. but go through the question once.. u will get it


Thread Starter

kowselyaa G

kowselyaa G

CA Final

2K+

06-Nov-23 20:14

It is a systemically important NBFC whose NPA classification period is 3 month


Thread Starter

kowselyaa G

kowselyaa G

CA Final

2K+

06-Nov-23 20:15

For systematically important non deposit accepting companies a account will be treated as sub standard only if it has been classifies as NPA for a period of more than 12 months. That's why I told you to read the provision. If it's Non systematically important the period is 18 months for it to be classified as sub standard.


Ashwin Kumar

Ashwin Kumar

CA Inter

12K+

06-Nov-23 20:19

For further reference please read this

Attachments

IMG_20231106_202100.jpg

Ashwin Kumar

Ashwin Kumar

CA Inter

12K+

06-Nov-23 20:21

Renu Madhav

Ok. It is less than 12m, but from how many months to 12m, is sub std

From being declared as NPA


Ashwin Kumar

Ashwin Kumar

CA Inter

12K+

06-Nov-23 20:52

In question they asked NBFC - D & SI

Attachments

Screenshot_2023_1106_205248.png

Renu Madhav

Renu Madhav

CA Inter

16K+

06-Nov-23 20:53

Ashwin Kumar

For further reference please read this

Yes .. it’s correct..once an standard asset becomes NPA .. it will be classified as sub standard asset for 12 months.. after that it will become doubtful asset.. but my ques is regarding how ICAI classied “75 accounts for 4 months” as standard asset.. How will u classify as an NPA for ND-SI & D nbfc ?

Attachments

539E8704-4FE6-40C6-8764-D40C809A15FA.jpg

Thread Starter

kowselyaa G

kowselyaa G

CA Final

2K+

06-Nov-23 21:00

Thread Starter

kowselyaa G

Yes .. it’s correct..once an standard asset becomes NPA .. it will be classified as sub standard asset for 12 months.. after that it will become doubtful asset.. but my ques is regarding how ICAI classied “75 accounts for 4 months” as standard asset.. How will u classify as an NPA for ND-SI & D nbfc ?

NOOOOO. Once there are no payments towards interest or principle or on demand or call for a period of three months it becomes "NPA" not "SUB STANDARD" if it stays NPA for a period of 12 months or more it becomes "SUB STANDARD" understand the provisions clearly. Your confusing the provisions of banking company with nbfc. In banking an account automatically becomes SUB STANDARD on being classified as NPA. in NBFC an account becomes SUB STANDARD after 12 months or 18 months depending upon SI or NSI becoming NPA. Understand the difference.


Ashwin Kumar

Ashwin Kumar

CA Inter

12K+

06-Nov-23 21:08

Your Reply