Supply

Actually D bit is also not a supply Because they indirectly mentioned that his brother is settled.

bsai partish

CA Final

★ 2K+

31-May-21 21:34

C- not a supply and D- supply

Likhitha Sivani

CA Final

★ 14K+

31-May-21 20:18

For D bit As his brother is not dependent on Raman He is not a related person So it is not a supply The actual point is Importation of services by related parties or establishment outside India in course or furtherance of business

Thread Starter

vijay anvesh

CA Final

★ 85

31-May-21 20:22

They didn't specified that he si not a dependent. In these type of questions they will definitely specify if the particular person is not a dependent

Likhitha Sivani

CA Final

★ 14K+

31-May-21 20:25

R u from master minds

Likhitha Sivani

CA Final

★ 14K+

31-May-21 21:37

Yes he is from MM

Thread Starter

vijay anvesh

CA Final

★ 85

31-May-21 21:57

Manaki chaala questions lo alaane untaay andi settled ane isthaaru okasaari similar questions icai material lo unnaay emo chuddaam

Likhitha Sivani

CA Final

★ 14K+

31-May-21 22:12

Haa yes same question icai material lo 6th one. Meeru cheppinattugaane teesukunnaaru. Thank u

Likhitha Sivani

CA Final

★ 14K+

31-May-21 22:18

Yes Konni dependent ani thesukunadu Konni independent ani thesukunadu

Thread Starter

vijay anvesh

CA Final

★ 85

31-May-21 22:18

Haa yes but icai vaallu independent ne teesukunnaaru. So ade follow avudaam

Likhitha Sivani

CA Final

★ 14K+

31-May-21 22:20

ð???ð???

Thread Starter

vijay anvesh

CA Final

★ 85

31-May-21 22:43

Yeah Okay

Thread Starter

vijay anvesh

CA Final

★ 85

31-May-21 22:43

Please clarify only in English in forums

Sudha Reddy

CA Final

★ 20K+

01-Jun-21 09:56

Import of services by a taxable person from a related person or from any of his other establishments outside India, for business purposes, will be treated as supply. (c) - its not for business purpose so not a supply (d) for business thus supply

Sudha Reddy

CA Final

★ 20K+

01-Jun-21 10:37