Forums

Capital structure

Financial Management

Why he has deducted value of debt net off tax

IMG-20201010-WA0009.jpg

Satya  Shashank

Satya Shashank

CA Inter

13K+

12-Oct-20 08:36

538

Answers (7)

.

IMG-20201010-WA0011.jpg

Thread Starter

Satya  Shashank

Satya Shashank

CA Inter

13K+

12-Oct-20 08:39

Thread Starter

Satya Shashank

.

Sorry this is the image

Screenshot_2020-10-12-08-39-37-01.png

Thread Starter

Satya  Shashank

Satya Shashank

CA Inter

13K+

12-Oct-20 08:40

Thread Starter

Satya Shashank

Sorry this is the image

This is from RTP May 2018 - the solution does not appear to be correct. Under Net operating income approach approach - value of a frim will not change due to capital structure as lower cost of debt will be offset by a higher cost of equity and when you capitalize equity earnings and add value of debt, the total value remains the same - that should be the ideal answer

NOI Approach.JPG

Sriram Somayajula

Sriram Somayajula

Admin

12-Oct-20 09:32

Thread Starter

Satya Shashank

Attachment is not opening

For attachment refer page 10 last para of link below https://resource.cdn.icai.org/56015bosinter45376-p8-seca-cp5.pdf Value of all equity firm will be Rs.20 Lacs and same will be the value for a levered frim under NOI approach. Part 2 of the answer is incorrect - correct answer is ( 20 lacs P & 20 lacs Q). Part 1 of solution is correct ( 32 lacs & 20 lacs) -


Sriram Somayajula

Sriram Somayajula

Admin

12-Oct-20 10:07

Individual Modules Offer
FR Reporting