Forums

Time of supply

Indirect Taxation

In the attached file, in the given example 6 , iii & iv questions answers are bit confusing. In case of a composition dealer the time of supply would be date of issue of invoice or receipt of payment whichever is earlier.....but in question iii they didn't consider receipt of payment why? And in question iv where did this 5th of August came from?

8a5b7a35-34fa-4b9f-9019-d7fae4435652.jpg
a01fd8a2-1502-49f2-9256-20aa676c34ed.jpg
d167a941-6677-4854-a78a-55cb54ce698b.jpg

srinidhi srinivas

srinidhi srinivas

CA Inter

8K+

11-Aug-22 10:10

193

Answers (5)

First of all,this question is not about composition scheme.So, forward charge will apply.Then, actual date of invoice or the date on which invoice must be raised becomes the time of supply.In iii) 1st August being the date of invoice,becomes the time of supply.


Shankari C

Shankari C

CA Inter

12K+

11-Aug-22 10:44

Shankari C

First of all,this question is not about composition scheme.So, forward charge will apply.Then, actual date of invoice or the date on which invoice must be raised becomes the time of supply.In iii) 1st August being the date of invoice,becomes the time of supply.

Thank you. But the provision also mentions the receipt of payment in the second point...i.e., the earliest amongst the two.

003343be-ce0b-40ae-a919-64f22225e78b.jpg

Thread Starter

srinidhi srinivas

srinidhi srinivas

CA Inter

8K+

11-Aug-22 10:53

There is amendment regarding this.Are you using old study material?


Shankari C

Shankari C

CA Inter

12K+

11-Aug-22 11:32

Shankari C

There is amendment regarding this.Are you using old study material?

Yes iam using old material. I'll go through the ammendment thanks for helping out!


Thread Starter

srinidhi srinivas

srinidhi srinivas

CA Inter

8K+

11-Aug-22 11:44

Thread Starter

srinidhi srinivas

Yes iam using old material. I'll go through the ammendment thanks for helping out!

Yea yeah go through the amendments.


Shankari C

Shankari C

CA Inter

12K+

11-Aug-22 12:33

2 day Offer